
Criteria for Information Classified as a Trade Secret
In an increasingly competitive business environment, a company's internal data and formulations can constitute some of its most valuable assets.
Under Article 1 point 1 in conjunction with Article 2 of Law No. 30 of 2000 on Trade Secrets, legal protection is provided for technological and business information such as production methods, engineered formulas, processing methods, and sales strategies that are confidential and commercially valuable to the company's business activities.
However, the law draws a clear boundary. A company cannot unilaterally classify all of its internal information as a Trade Secret.
Referring to Article 3 paragraph (1) of the Trade Secrets Law, there are three mandatory and interconnected criteria:
Confidentiality: The information is not generally known to the public or competing business operators.
Economic Value: The confidentiality of the information contributes to financial success or creates additional commercial value for the company.
Measures to Maintain Confidentiality: The rights holder must demonstrate that reasonable steps have been taken to maintain confidentiality, for example by requiring employees to enter into confidentiality agreements or Non-Disclosure Agreements and by protecting sensitive documents using encryption and adequate security protocols.
Without simultaneous fulfilment of these three criteria, a claim that information constitutes a Trade Secret may fail, making it more difficult to apply the enforcement mechanisms available under the Trade Secrets Law.
Licensing
Article 4 of the Trade Secrets Law provides that the owner of a Trade Secret has the right to use the Trade Secret personally and to grant a licence to, or prohibit, another party from using or disclosing the Trade Secret to a third party for commercial purposes.
A Trade Secret rights holder may grant a licence to another party or third party under a licensing agreement authorizing the relevant use.
The licensing agreement must be recorded with the Directorate General subject to the applicable fee and subsequently announced in the Trade Secrets Gazette.
A Trade Secret licensing agreement that is not recorded with the Directorate General has no legal effect against third parties.
A licensing agreement is prohibited from containing provisions that may adversely affect the Indonesian economy or result in unfair business competition in violation of applicable laws and regulations.
Unlike an agreement that forms the basis for the permanent transfer of Trade Secret rights, a licence only grants limited rights for a limited period.
Accordingly, a licence authorizes the use or utilization of a Trade Secret only for a specified period.
The control of a Trade Secret not only provides a competitive advantage, but also gives its owner legal authority to determine how that information may be commercially exploited.
Referring to Article 4 of the Trade Secrets Law, the right to use a Trade Secret belongs to the rights holder, including the legal authority to grant licences or prohibit any party from disclosing it to third parties for economic purposes.
Commercialization of Trade Secrets through licensing must nevertheless comply with the legal requirements provided under Articles 8 and 9 of the Trade Secrets Law:
A licensing agreement must be recorded with the Directorate General of Intellectual Property and announced in the Trade Secrets Gazette. Without official recordation, the licensing agreement cannot legally be asserted or enforced against third parties.
A licensing agreement is prohibited from containing restrictive clauses that harm the Indonesian economy or violate the principles of fair business competition.
Unlike a permanent transfer of ownership rights, a licence only permits the use of a Trade Secret for a specified period.
Given the significant confidentiality risks involved, the implementation of a Trade Secret licence has its own particular characteristics.
The transfer of information may not simply involve the delivery of standard documents, but may instead take place through direct assistance by trusted experts.
This approach differs fundamentally from ordinary operational technical assistance because it combines the transfer of knowledge with strict measures designed to preserve the confidential nature of the information.
Dispute Resolution
Under civil law, Trade Secret protection is supported by enforcement mechanisms intended to restore the rights of an injured rights holder.
Where confidential business information is stolen, disclosed, or used without authorization for another party's commercial benefit, the Trade Secret rights holder or licensee may pursue legal remedies.
Under Article 11 of the Trade Secrets Law, the injured party has the right to bring a claim against the infringing party before the District Court.
Through litigation, the claimant may seek two forms of relief simultaneously: payment of financial damages arising from the business loss and an order requiring the immediate cessation of all unauthorized use of the Trade Secret.
On the other hand, the public nature of court proceedings may create a separate dilemma for Trade Secret owners who wish to prevent their confidential business information from becoming more widely exposed.
To accommodate this concern, Article 12 of the Trade Secrets Law permits disputes to be resolved privately through Arbitration or Alternative Dispute Resolution.
Through negotiation, mediation, or conciliation, the parties may seek a mutually acceptable solution in a forum that is closed to the public, thereby allowing the confidentiality of the Trade Secret to remain better protected during the dispute-resolution process.
Legal Sanctions
The termination of an employment relationship is sometimes incorrectly interpreted by former employees as ending all of their legal responsibilities toward their former employer.
However, under Trade Secret law, the unauthorized disclosure of internal information by a former employee may constitute a criminal offence.
Article 13 of the Trade Secrets Law provides that a breach of trust, violation of a written or unwritten confidentiality obligation, or unauthorized disclosure of confidential business information constitutes an infringement of Trade Secret rights.
This responsibility continues because rights to use confidential company information are not perpetual.
Referring to the Elucidation of Article 6 of the Trade Secrets Law, a licence or right of access granted to an employee during employment is limited in both scope and duration.
Once the employment relationship ends, the former employee becomes an external party without legal authority to control, use, or disclose the former employer's confidential business information.
As a consequence of such unlawful conduct, the law provides for strict sanctions.
Under Article 17 paragraph (1) of the Trade Secrets Law, a breach of confidentiality obligations may be subject to imprisonment for up to 2 years and/or a maximum fine of IDR 300,000,000.
This provision protects a company's intellectual assets from unauthorized control or use while emphasizing that disclosure of confidential business information by a former employee can result in substantial legal consequences.
Conclusion
Based on the discussion above, resignation or termination of employment does not automatically eliminate a former employee's legal obligation to protect the company's Trade Secrets, because access rights obtained during employment are limited and cease once the employment relationship ends, as explained in the Elucidation of Article 6 of the Trade Secrets Law.
Where the disclosed information satisfies the legal criteria for a Trade Secret under Article 3 of the Trade Secrets Law, a former employee who discloses or uses that confidential business information without authorization has committed a breach of obligation and an unlawful act under Article 13 of the Trade Secrets Law.
For such infringement, the company may pursue civil remedies before the District Court, including damages and cessation of the unlawful conduct under Article 11, use a confidential dispute-resolution mechanism through Arbitration under Article 12, and report the matter as a criminal offence carrying a maximum sentence of 2 years' imprisonment and/or a maximum fine of IDR 300,000,000 under Article 17 paragraph (1) of the Trade Secrets Law.
Summary
An employee's resignation or termination does not automatically eliminate the legal obligation to protect confidential information belonging to a former employer. The disclosure of trade secrets by a former employee, whether involving formulas, production methods, recipes, client data, or business strategies, may constitute an unlawful act with serious legal consequences. Under Indonesian law, a former employee who discloses or uses a former employer's trade secrets without authorization may face civil liability through damages claims, imprisonment and fines, as well as other criminal consequences under the Trade Secrets Law.
Legal Basis & References
Law No. 30 of 2000 on Trade Secrets
Tags
Trade Secrets
Former Employees
Corporate Confidentiality
Non-Disclosure Agreement
Intellectual Property
Trade Secret Infringement
Trade Secret Licensing
Intellectual Property Disputes

Need Legal Advice?
Our team is ready to assist you with practical solution

